15 Fictional Musicals We Wish Were Real

Over the years, movies such as “The Producers” and TV shows such as “Smash” have shared the common trope of the fictional musical. Certain nonexistent stage musicals have been lucky enough to get their own concert production, while others are still awaiting their own moment in the spotlight.
Here are 15 fictional musicals we think deserve their own full-length stage production:

1. ‘Put That Thing Back Where It Came From, Or So Help Me!’ from ‘Monsters, Inc.’

In the credits of “Monsters, Inc.,” Mike, Sully and the whole company reenact the movie’s story as a musical. It’s quite the scream!

2. ‘Rochelle, Rochelle’ from ‘Seinfeld’

In the series’ sixth season, Bette Midler guest-stars to perform in the musical “Rochelle, Rochelle.” After George accidentally injures her in a softball game, her understudy, Gennice, performs in her place. The episode is partially inspired by the Nancy Kerrigan incident.

3. ‘Influenza: The Musical’ from ‘Even Stevens’

This episode documents Ren’s bizarre school day as she suffers from the flu while trying to keep her perfect attendance record.

4. ‘Eliza Rocks!’ from ‘Confessions of a Teenage Drama Queen’

This pop-rock version of “Pygmalion” features Lindsay Lohan’s character as a modern-day Eliza Doolittle.

5. ‘Freud! The Musical’ from ‘Friends’

The level of cringe in Joey Tribbiani’s musical about the famous neurologist leaves room for its own psychoanalysis.

6. ‘Twinkle Towne’ from ‘High School Musical’

The musical-within-a-musical contains gems such as “Bop to the Top” and “Breaking Free.”

7. ‘LA Bretto’ from ‘Dexter’s Laboratory’

This one-of-a-kind episode in the series is about the famed boy genius’ birth and how he created his laboratory.

8. ‘The Nightman Cometh’ from ‘It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia’

The season four finale features Charlie Kelly writing a musical and casting the main characters in it as an attempt to propose to the Waitress.

9. ‘Oh, Streetcar!’ from ‘The Simpsons’

In the fourth season, Marge plays Blanche DuBois in a local musical version of “A Streetcar Named Desire,” complete with some controversial lyrics about New Orleans.

10. ‘Romeo Must Wed’ from ‘The Proud Family’

Penny and her crush, Kwok, star as Juliet and Romeo in their school play and add a hip-hop twist to the final scene.

11. ’Thomas Edison/Topsy’ from ‘Bob’s Burgers’

The third season features a musical number that Gene writes about Thomas Edison and the electrocution of Topsy the Elephant.

12. ‘Snow White and the Seven Dorks’ from ‘Saved by the Bell’

fictional musicals, theatre nerds

Similarly to aforementioned “Proud Family” episode, the main characters of “Saved By the Bell” make a hip-hop version of “Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs.”

13. ‘Helen Keller! The Musical’ from ‘South Park’

Cartman decides to turn Helen Keller’s life story into a musical, with professional actor Jeffrey Maynard surprising everyone by playing the late author-activist herself.

14. ’The Deo Variety Hour’ from ‘Foster’s Home for Imaginary Friends’

The Hollywood agent Kip Snip turns Bloo into the new face of Deo, a deodorant brand. However, Bloo sneaks his qualms with Snip into the lyrics of the songs he performs.

15. ‘Mr. G: The Musical’ from ‘Summer Heights High’

Mr. G., a flamboyant and egocentric drama teacher, turns his life story (and a student’s drug overdose) into a musical spectacular.

Did we leave out your favorite fictional musical? Let us know in the comments below…

Written by Joseph Kisiday

Joseph Kisiday is a 2016 graduate from Christopher Newport University, majoring in Music Composition. Joseph's love for theatre came at a young age through discovering the musicals of Andrew Lloyd Webber, such as "Cats" and "The Phantom of the Opera." When he is not writing, Joseph can be found watching operas or Miyazaki films.


Leave a Reply

Leave a Reply

smash tv show quiz, smash show, smash quiz, smash bombshell

Quiz: How Well Do You Remember ‘Smash’?

falsettos trivia, falsettos musical

Quiz: How Well Do You Know Falsettos?