We asked you Theatre Nerds what what movies you think should be made into Broadway musicals. After receiving over 400 responses, there were some clear winners. Providing a full disclaimer, some of these shows have been made (or attempted) into musicals, but have either flopped or not made it to the Broadway stage.

Two of the top voted movies also have upcoming productions so we left them off the list. These two were: Mean Girls & Back To The Future. Some of our favorites that didn’t quite make the list: Godfather (a parody version) & Jurassic Park!

Here are your top 15 movies that should be made into Broadway musicals:

15. Spaceballs – 19 Nerd Votes

14. The Sandlot – 25 Nerd votes

13. Clue – 28 Nerd Votes

12. Hercules – 30 Nerd Votes

11. Pirates of the Caribbean – 34 Nerd Votes

10. The Goonies – 35 Nerd Votes

9. Ferris Bueller’s Day Off – 36 Nerd Votes

8. The Perks of Being a Wallflower – 39 Nerd Votes

7. Labyrinth – 43 Nerd Votes

6. Napoleon Dynamite – 49 Nerd Votes

5. The Princess Diaries – 58 Nerd Votes

4. The Great Gatsby – 62 Nerd Votes

3. Monsters, Inc. – 76 Nerd Votes

2. The Breakfast Club – 83 Nerd Votes

1. The Princess Bride – 91 Nerd Votes

What movie would you like to see as a musical? Leave a reply below…